← All teardowns · Home builder · Grok

Why Grok recommends Ivory Homes over Garbett Homes for geothermal and solar-ready homes in Salt Lake City

Garbett has built solar and geothermal homes in Utah since 2012. Asked which SLC builder offers them, ChatGPT names 7 builders, Grok 3. Neither names Garbett.

Target
Garbett Homes
vs
Winner
Ivory Homes
Prompt which Utah homebuilder offers geothermal options and solar ready homes in the SLC area
Published November 4, 2026 · Updated November 4, 2026

Garbett Homes builds energy-efficient homes in the Salt Lake City area and sells its quick move-in homes through a Shopify store, one listing per lot. Its own timeline says it built Utah’s first solar-powered homes under $250,000 in 2009 and expanded solar and geothermal across its product line in 2012.

Across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok, and Claude, Garbett is named in 79 of 100 responses, and its Citelix GeoScore is 74 out of 100. That is a strong score, and almost all of it comes from prompts that already say “Garbett.”

Garbett Homes Citelix GeoScore 74 out of 100, brand named in 79 of 100 AI responses: ChatGPT 18, Gemini 20, Perplexity 5, Grok 17, Claude 19 of 20 prompts

The prompt I tested

The scan ran 20 prompts. The anchor for this teardown:

“which Utah homebuilder offers geothermal options and solar ready homes in the SLC area”

Why this prompt: it is the question Garbett’s green building history was made to answer, asked by a buyer who has not heard of Garbett yet.

What the AI models said

Two models named Garbett. Two did not, and one returned nothing.

I picked Ivory Homes as the winner because it is the only builder other than Garbett named by two models here, and the most-named competitor across the scan’s discovery prompts.

The discovery gap

On the 17 prompts that name Garbett, the models name it in 73 of 85 answers. On the 3 that do not, they name it in 6 of 15.

The discovery gap: Garbett is named in 73 of 85 brand-aware answers and 6 of 15 discovery answers

The 15 include 3 empty Perplexity answers, and on the geothermal prompt the two models that skipped Garbett are ChatGPT and Grok.

Why Ivory Homes won on Grok

1. Grok wanted a spec sheet, and Garbett’s listings have none

Grok answered with equipment brands, loop types, price adders, and community names for each builder. I could not confirm any of Grok’s details for Edge, Holmes, or Ivory, and I do not repeat them here. But that is the shape of the answer it wanted. On garbetthomes.com, none of the 54 home listings mention energy, insulation, heat pumps, solar, or geothermal in their descriptions.

2. Garbett’s geothermal story is a line in a timeline

The only page on garbetthomes.com I found that says “geothermal” is the “Utah’s Green Builder” timeline: “2012 - Garbett Homes expands the Solar and Geothermal technology across it’s entire product-line of homes.” Gemini and Claude found it. The 2022 entry says Garbett now builds Zero Emission homes. No page says whether geothermal is still offered today.

3. The current spec has a name the models never use

Garbett’s FAQ describes “Efficiency+ by Garbett”: enhanced insulation, air sealing, advanced HVAC systems, and low-E windows. The next answer explains heat pump technology. No model mentioned Efficiency+ on the geothermal prompt. It lives on an FAQ page, not on the listings.

4. ChatGPT filled the gap with guesses

ChatGPT’s top pick came with its own caveat that the builder’s website does not mention geothermal. When the source pages are thin, the model lists builders it can find and hedges. Garbett, with a 2012 timeline line as its geothermal evidence, did not make the list.

Discovery prompts: Garbett named in 6 of 15 answers, Ivory Homes 3, Sego Homes 2, Fieldstone, Edge and Holmes Homes 1 each

What Garbett is missing

I checked garbetthomes.com. It has 54 home listings, 36 pages, and no blog: /blogs/news returns 404. The Sargent A.2 listing I checked has Product schema with offers in the server HTML. The FAQ page answers 11 questions. Here is what is missing:

Recommended actions ranked by impact score: add detailed home descriptions (85), add alt text to listing images (80), start a blog on energy efficiency (75)

3 fixes Garbett could ship this week

Fix 1: Add an energy block to every listing

Why this matters: buyers ask about efficiency, and the listing is the page a model finds for a specific home.

How to do it: Under each listing’s price, add five lines: HVAC system (heat pump or geothermal), insulation spec, windows, solar status (included, optional, or pre-wired), and the HERS score if Garbett has one. Write it once per plan and reuse it per lot.

Estimated time: 1 day for all 54 listings.

Fix 2: Publish one page on geothermal and solar today

Why this matters: the prompt asks a direct question, and Garbett’s only answer is a 2012 timeline line.

How to do it: A page titled “Geothermal and solar-ready homes in Salt Lake City” that says which communities offer what now, what Efficiency+ includes, and what changed from geothermal to all-electric. Link it from every listing and the FAQ.

Estimated time: 2 to 3 hours.

Fix 3: Mark up the FAQ and add alt text

Why this matters: the FAQ already answers heat pump and solar questions; schema makes those answers easy to lift.

How to do it: Add FAQPage schema to /pages/faq. Then add alt text to listing images that names the plan and the feature shown, starting with the quick move-in homes.

Estimated time: half a day.

The 30-second version

If you only do one thing: put the energy specs on every home listing. Garbett is named in 73 of 85 answers that ask about it, but when a buyer asks which SLC builder offers geothermal and solar-ready homes, ChatGPT names seven builders and Grok three, and neither names the builder that has done it since 2012.

Methodology

I ran this scan through Citelix on 2026-11-04 (pro-tier, 20 prompts across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok, and Claude, 100 responses in total, Claude collected via batch). The GeoScore of 74 is the scan’s final score after the Claude responses landed.

Perplexity returned an empty answer on 15 of the 20 prompts, including the anchor. I counted those as misses, which is why Perplexity shows 5 hits. Brand counts come from a whole-word search for “Garbett” in the response text; my total of 79 is one higher than the scan’s own count of 78. Builder names in the discovery chart come from the response text; Ivory, Sego, Fieldstone, Edge, and Holmes were not all in the scan’s tracked list.

I could not verify Grok’s equipment, price, or community details for Edge Homes, Holmes Homes, or Ivory Homes, so I do not repeat them. I kept three of the scan’s seven actions and note FAQ schema (65) as also valid; “Add Expert Quotes” (60) and “Submit Business for Review on Reviewed.com” (55) were left out as lower impact for a home builder. Site facts come from garbetthomes.com on 2026-11-04. This teardown is independent and not sponsored by either company.


Want this teardown for your store? Install Citelix on Shopify. We scan your store across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, and Grok every day and tell you exactly which prompts your competitors win and what to change.

Keep reading
How to get your Shopify store recommended by ChatGPT
Best AI visibility tools for Shopify (2026)
Browse all teardowns

Is your store in this data — or missing from it?

See your store’s GeoScore — free.

We run your store across Grok and 4 other AI platforms, show you which prompts your competitors win, and send you the exact fixes that move you into recommendations. No install required to see your score.

Get your free scan → Or install on Shopify

Free · No credit card · Full report emailed within 24h